Engineering Guide · Vendor-Neutral

Miles & Misra vs Spread Plate vs Drop Plate: Which CFU Method Should You Use?

Miles and Misra sectored drop plate vs full-surface spread plate vs Herigstad optimised drop plate side-by-side comparison 10⁻¹ 10⁻² 10⁻³ 10⁻⁴ Miles & Misra 8 sectors · 20 µL drops 6 dilutions / plate VS VS Spread Plate Whole surface · 100-200 µL 1 dilution / plate · 25-250 CFU Drop Plate 25 drops · 10 µL Herigstad 2001 optimised
Figure 1: Three CFU enumeration geometries. Miles & Misra sectors six to eight dilutions on one plate; the spread plate covers the whole surface with one dilution; the Herigstad 2001 optimised drop plate replicates one dilution across a 5 x 5 grid.
Quick Verdict

Pick the spread plate for release testing, Miles & Misra for scanning an unknown density, and the Herigstad optimised drop plate for high-throughput research. All three measure the same colony forming units per millilitre, but they trade plate count, media use, and regulatory acceptance. The spread plate is the pharmacopoeial default (Ph. Eur. 2.6.12, USP 61, FDA BAM Chapter 3); Miles & Misra covers six dilutions on one plate and ships with eighty-eight years of literature; the optimised drop plate (Herigstad et al. 2001) matches spread-plate precision at a fraction of the plastic.

Key differences at a glance

Side-by-side comparison

Factor Miles & Misra Spread plate Drop plate (Herigstad)
Inoculum volume 20 µL per sector 100 to 200 µL per plate 10 µL per drop
Dilutions per plate 6 to 8 (sectored) 1 1 (replicated 20 to 25 times)
Countable range 2 to 20 colonies per drop 25 to 250 CFU per plate 3 to 30 colonies per drop
Typical CV (replicated) 15 to 20 percent 10 to 15 percent 10 to 15 percent
Plates per unknown sample 1 plate scans 6 dilutions 3 to 5 plates to bracket 1 plate per dilution guess
Agar and plastic per count Lowest (one plate) Highest (one plate per dilution) Low (one plate, many replicates)
Operator time per count 8 to 12 min plating + 20 min counting 5 min per plate plating + 10 min counting 6 to 10 min plating + 15 min counting
Incubation time 16 to 24 h (read small) 18 to 48 h (standard) 16 to 24 h (read small)
Regulatory acceptance Research / in-house only Pharmacopoeial (Ph. Eur., USP, BAM) Research / high-throughput QC

CV figures follow Hedges 2002. The spread-plate range of 25 to 250 CFU is the FDA BAM endorsement for aerobic plate counts.

Miles & Misra in detail

The surface viable count described by Miles, Misra, and Irwin in 1938 was designed to measure how fast whole blood kills Staphylococcus aureus. Their problem was logistical. A single bactericidal timepoint needs six serial dilutions, and six spread plates per timepoint was expensive in agar, plastic, and incubator space. The paper's answer was to divide one agar plate into six or eight equal sectors and pipette a 20 microlitre drop of each dilution onto its own sector. One plate, one timepoint, all six dilutions at once.

How it works

You prepare a 10-fold serial dilution series (typically 10⁻¹ through 10⁻⁶ or 10⁻⁷) in sterile diluent. A pre-dried agar plate is marked on its base into sectors. From the highest dilution first, 20 microlitre drops are pipetted onto the agar surface of each sector; the drops are allowed to soak in without spreading. The plate is incubated right-side-up at the species-appropriate temperature until drops produce discrete colonies, read while colonies are still small enough to be distinct (16 to 24 hours for E. coli at 37°C). The sector with 2 to 20 colonies per drop is the readable one, and the CFU per millilitre of the original sample is the colony count divided by the drop volume multiplied by the reciprocal of that sector's dilution factor. Three replicate drops per dilution is the minimum for a credible density estimate, which usually means two or three sectored plates total.

When Miles & Misra wins

Miles & Misra is the natural choice whenever you do not know the starting density within a factor of 10. A 10⁴-fold dilution range covered on one plate guarantees that at least one sector lands inside the countable window regardless of how far the starting density is from your guess. That is why environmental monitoring programmes in water, soil, and food pre-processing still use the sector layout. It is also the default for teaching microbiology, because every student's plate yields readable results on the first attempt without the operator knowing the sample strength. The method stays popular in quantitative microbiology textbooks as the "surface viable count" alongside pour and spread plating.

Spread plate in detail

The spread plate is the reference aerobic plate count method captured in FDA BAM Chapter 3, in European Pharmacopoeia 2.6.12, and in USP <61> for non-sterile pharmaceutical products. It is the default assay whenever a colony count ends up in a regulated document.

How it works

A 10-fold serial dilution series is prepared and 100 to 200 microlitres of one dilution is pipetted onto a pre-dried agar plate. The inoculum is spread across the entire agar surface with a bent glass rod, a disposable L-shaped spreader, or with 4 to 8 sterile glass beads that are rolled across the surface (the Copacabana method). The plate is inverted and incubated until countable colonies appear. The spread-plate countable range is 25 to 250 CFU per plate for most aerobic organisms (FDA BAM Chapter 3). CFU per millilitre is colony count divided by plated volume (in mL) multiplied by the reciprocal of the dilution factor. The method expects three to five plates covering adjacent dilutions so that at least one lands inside the 25 to 250 countable range.

When the spread plate wins

Use the spread plate whenever the result goes into a release certificate or a regulatory filing. It wins when the sample density is known within a factor of 10 so you can target the countable range with one or two dilutions. It also wins for colony-morphology work (presumptive identification, picking single colonies for downstream MALDI or sequencing) because each colony has a full field of agar around it and nothing is crowded into a 5 mm drop. In practice, most food and pharmaceutical microbiology labs run spread or pour plates as their primary quantitative method and keep Miles & Misra as the troubleshooting tool.

Drop plate (Herigstad 2001) in detail

The drop plate is the modern successor to Miles & Misra. The Herigstad, Hamilton & Heersink paper in Journal of Microbiological Methods 44(2):121-129 used computer simulation and regression to derive the standard deviation of the drop-plate density estimate as a function of beaker volume, dilution factor, and plated volume. Their contribution was not the technique (Miles & Misra already existed) but the statistical optimisation of how many drops, what volume per drop, and what dilution factor minimise the final coefficient of variation.

How it works

A 10-fold serial dilution series is prepared and 10 microlitre drops are pipetted onto a single agar plate in a grid, typically 5 by 5 (25 drops) or 4 by 5 (20 drops), of one dilution per plate. Drops are allowed to soak in and the plate is incubated to small colonies (16 to 24 hours for fast-growing aerobes). Only drops with 3 to 30 colonies are counted; drops above 30 are excluded for colony merging and drops below 3 for Poisson error. The paper's key finding is that the drop-plate standard-deviation expression is the same as for spread plating, which means the drop plate achieves equivalent precision when its volume and dilution factor are chosen correctly.

When the drop plate wins

The drop plate wins on three criteria: throughput, consumables cost, and incubator space. A high-throughput biofilm or antimicrobial susceptibility screen that would need 400 spread plates (4 dilutions × 100 samples) fits on 100 drop plates (1 dilution × 100 samples, 25 replicates each). The Herigstad 2001 design is the default method in the Montana State University Center for Biofilm Engineering, which is why it appears in every biofilm MIC and MBEC protocol. A 2013 Veterinary Research Forum comparison on Lactobacillus casei and Salmonella Typhimurium reported that the drop method could replace spread plating in routine viable counting without loss of precision. What the drop plate still does not get is pharmacopoeial acceptance, which keeps the spread plate in the release-test slot.

Pros and cons

Miles & Misra

Advantages

  • Six to eight dilutions on one plate; always hits the countable window regardless of starting density.
  • Lowest agar and plastic consumption of the three methods per final density estimate.
  • Eighty-eight years of literature; universally understood by microbiologists and reviewers.
  • Reads in 16 to 24 hours because drops are small and colonies stay separated.

Disadvantages

  • No pharmacopoeial recognition; results are research-grade or in-house only.
  • Precision pipetting of 20 microlitre drops is the dominant error source.
  • Each drop counts only 2 to 20 colonies, so single-drop Poisson error is high; needs three replicate drops per dilution.
  • Must be read before colonies grow enough to merge across sector boundaries.

Spread plate

Advantages

  • Pharmacopoeial reference method (Ph. Eur. 2.6.12, USP 61, FDA BAM Chapter 3).
  • Highest colonies per data point (25 to 250), so the lowest Poisson relative error per plate.
  • Colonies have full surrounding agar for morphology, picking, and presumptive identification.
  • Compatible with every laboratory information management system that logs "plate count".

Disadvantages

  • Highest plate count per sample: three to five plates to bracket an unknown dilution.
  • Highest agar, plastic, and incubator space consumption of the three.
  • Spreading can damage delicate or fast-moving cells (Proteus, swarmers) if the surface is too moist.
  • Slower read because colonies grow to a size that fills a 90 mm plate (18 to 48 hours).

Drop plate (Herigstad)

Advantages

  • Statistically optimised: Herigstad 2001 derives the dilution and volume that minimise CV.
  • Twenty to 25 built-in replicates per dilution on one plate; CV drops to 10 to 15 percent routinely.
  • Highest throughput of the three; fits automated multi-channel pipetting and plate-stamping arrays.
  • Lowest reagent cost per data point for screening scale (biofilm MIC, antimicrobial screens).

Disadvantages

  • Requires an initial density estimate so one dilution can hit the countable window.
  • Not pharmacopoeial; QC labs may need a parallel spread plate on release batches.
  • Agar surface must be bone dry; a slightly wet plate lets drops merge and the grid collapses.
  • Operators new to the layout tend to under-replicate; three-drop minimum must be enforced in SOPs.

Which should you choose?

Three constraints dominate: regulatory scope, whether the density is known within a factor of 10, and how many samples you are counting per day.

Release testing for a regulated product

The number goes on a certificate of analysis or into a regulatory filing. Ph. Eur. 2.6.12, USP <61>, and FDA BAM Chapter 3 all call for spread or pour plating, not drop plating, and reviewers are familiar with the 25 to 250 CFU per plate countable range.

Choose spread plate

Unknown starting density, environmental sample

Natural water, soil, wastewater, or a fermentation sample from an unusual timepoint where the density could be 10³ or 10⁹ CFU per mL. Miles & Misra covers that 10⁴-fold range on one plate so at least one sector lands in the countable window on the first attempt.

Choose Miles & Misra

High-throughput screening or biofilm MIC

100 to 1,000 samples per week in a biofilm MIC, antimicrobial susceptibility screen, or probiotic release count where the density is already known within a factor of 10 from the previous passage.

Choose drop plate

Teaching lab or microbiology training

Students need a result on their first attempt without the instructor knowing the exact density of the test culture. The Miles & Misra layout guarantees a readable sector regardless of how well the student prepared the dilution series, which is why it is the default teaching method in UK, Australian, and Indian undergraduate microbiology practicals.

Choose Miles & Misra

Real-world use cases

Typical setups where microbiology labs have converged on one method or another.

Pharmaceutical release
USP <61> non-sterile product testing

Spread plate on soybean casein digest agar (TSA) at 30 to 35°C, 25 to 250 CFU per plate countable range, three to five plates per sample covering adjacent dilutions. Required method for release of non-sterile pharmaceuticals.

Biofilm research
CDC biofilm reactor MBEC

Drop plate on TSA using the Herigstad 2001 20 µL optimisation. 25 drops per coupon dislodge-and-dilution sample, read at 16 hours. Standard assay in the Montana State University Center for Biofilm Engineering biofilm MBEC protocol.

Water microbiology
Potable water heterotrophic count

Miles & Misra on R2A agar at 22°C for 72 hours. Eight-sector layout covers 10 to 10⁶ CFU per mL on one plate, which matches the density range of reservoir, mains, and point-of-use water samples.

Probiotic QC
Lactobacillus / Bifidobacterium release count

Drop plate or spread plate on MRS or MRS-cysteine agar (anaerobe pouches). Drop plate wins on throughput when a probiotic manufacturer runs 50 to 100 batch release counts per week; spread plate wins when the count is on the certificate of analysis for a regulated dietary supplement.

Need to plan the dilution series before you plate?

The cell counting calculator handles the hemocytometer and CFU plate-count maths in one tool. Enter your dilution factor and counted colonies or cells and get density per millilitre without the paper notebook.

Open the Cell Counting Calculator

Cost and consumable considerations

Cost per final density estimate, not per plate

The spread plate uses more plates per sample. Miles & Misra and the Herigstad drop plate use fewer. At scale, that moves the per-sample cost by 3 to 5x because an operator-hour, 90 mm petri dish, and 25 mL of agar add up quickly across 50 to 1,000 samples per week. The right comparison is cost per final CFU/mL estimate, not cost per plate.

A single CFU count from a spread plate typically costs 2 to 3 petri dishes (bracketing 3 dilutions), 50 to 75 mL of agar, three sterile L-spreaders or a bag of beads, and 15 to 20 operator minutes. Over 100 samples that is 200 to 300 plates, 5 to 7.5 L of agar, and 25 to 33 operator-hours.

A Miles & Misra count costs one sectored plate, about 25 mL of agar, no spreader, and 15 minutes of operator time. The drop plate (Herigstad 20-drop layout) costs one plate, 25 mL of agar, and 10 to 15 operator minutes. At 100 samples per week the drop plate and Miles & Misra each save 70 to 100 plates and 15 to 25 operator-hours per week versus a straight spread-plate workflow. On a research or probiotic QC budget that is one FTE-week per year reallocated to higher-value work.

Cost component (per 100 samples) Miles & Misra Spread plate Drop plate
Petri dishes~100250 to 300~100
Agar volume~2.5 L~6 to 7.5 L~2.5 L
Spreaders / beads0300 spreaders or 3 bead bags0
Operator time~25 h~30 h~22 h
Per-100-sample consumable cost (indicative)~$80 to $120~$220 to $340~$80 to $120

Equipment and consumables landscape

CFU methods are inherently low-tech. Vendors in this space supply the plates, the dispensers, and the colony counters; the method itself is a protocol decision.

Automated colony counters

Plate dispensers and liquid handling

Agar and plates

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between Miles & Misra, spread plate, and drop plate methods?
Miles & Misra is a surface viable count described by Miles, Misra, and Irwin in 1938: an agar plate is divided into six or eight sectors and a 20 microlitre drop of each dilution in a serial series is placed on its own sector. The spread plate is the standard aerobic plate count method captured in FDA BAM Chapter 3: a 100 to 200 microlitre inoculum of one dilution is spread across the whole agar surface with a glass spreader or sterile beads. The drop plate in the Herigstad 2001 optimisation is a statistically engineered version of the Miles & Misra idea: typically 10 microlitre drops of one dilution per plate, with volume and dilution factor chosen to minimise the standard deviation of the density estimate.
Which CFU method is most accurate?
The spread plate is the reference method, with a well-understood countable range of 25 to 250 CFU per plate and typical coefficient of variation of 10 to 15 percent on a single dilution. Herigstad 2001 showed that the drop plate reaches equivalent precision to spread plating when volume and dilution are chosen correctly, and the same standard-deviation expression applies to both methods. Miles & Misra is the least precise of the three in individual colony count terms because each 20 microlitre sector counts far fewer colonies, but it scans multiple dilutions per plate so it hits the countable range reliably even when the true density is unknown.
Why does Miles & Misra use sectored plates?
Sectoring puts six or eight dilutions of the same sample on one agar plate. Miles, Misra, and Irwin designed it that way in 1938 so that the bactericidal power of blood could be measured across a 10 to 100 thousand fold density range using one plate per timepoint instead of six. The practical consequence today is low media and plastic use, high throughput per operator-hour, and natural coverage of any density because at least one sector will land inside the countable 2 to 20 colonies per drop window.
What is the countable range for the drop plate method?
Classic Miles & Misra guidance is 2 to 20 colonies per drop (approximately 20 microlitres). Herigstad and colleagues 2001 recommend counting only drops that fall between 3 and 30 colonies, and they derive the volume-to-dilution balance that keeps as many drops as possible in that window. Above 30 colonies per drop, the colonies merge and are undercounted. Below 3, the Poisson sampling error grows faster than the density reading is useful. In every case, replicate three drops at minimum so the coefficient of variation drops below 20 percent.
When should I use spread plate over Miles & Misra?
Use the spread plate when the result goes into a regulatory report or pharmacopoeial release test (Ph. Eur. 2.6.12, USP 61, FDA BAM Chapter 3 all specify spread or pour plating, not drop plating). Use spread plating when the density is already known within a factor of 10 so you can target a single dilution at 25 to 250 CFU per plate. Use spread plating when colony morphology at full plate resolution matters, for example reading a presumptive identification from the colony appearance or picking single colonies for downstream work. Keep Miles & Misra for research-scale density scanning where you do not know the starting density.
Is drop plate as accurate as spread plate?
Yes, when the Herigstad 2001 design is applied. The paper derived the standard deviation of the density estimate as a function of beaker volume, dilution factor, and drop volume, and showed that the same expression applies to both drop and spread plating. The 2013 Veterinary Research Forum comparison of drop versus spread plating on Lactobacillus casei and Salmonella Typhimurium reported a strong positive correlation (p less than 0.001), and the authors concluded the drop method could replace spread plating in routine work. Where the spread plate retains an edge is regulatory acceptance.
How many colonies should I count per plate?
For the spread plate, FDA BAM endorses the 25 to 250 CFU per plate countable range for most aerobic plate counts. For the drop plate, Herigstad 2001 recommends the 3 to 30 colonies per drop window, which corresponds to roughly 150 CFU per mL at the low end for a 20 microlitre drop. For Miles & Misra, count only sectors with 2 to 20 discrete colonies and average across three replicate sectors. In every case, counts below the lower limit have unacceptable Poisson error, and counts above the upper limit undercount from colony coalescence.
What is the difference between pour plate and spread plate?
The spread plate puts the inoculum on top of solid agar and spreads it across the surface, so colonies grow on the surface and are visible for picking. The pour plate adds the inoculum to molten agar at 40 to 45 degrees Celsius and then pours the mixture into the plate, so colonies grow embedded in the agar and form smaller lenticular shapes. Pour plating is the dominant method in food microbiology (FDA BAM Chapter 3 keeps both as options) and in anaerobe work because the embedded agar limits oxygen exposure. Neither is a drop plate method: this comparison keeps the pour plate out of scope and treats it as a separate downstream decision inside the spread plate family.
Do I need technical replicates with the drop plate method?
Yes, at least three drop replicates per dilution. Hedges 2002 shows mathematically that replicating the final plating step improves precision, while averaging across multiple dilutions can degrade it for the standard pour plate count. In practice this means three drops of the same dilution for drop plate and Miles & Misra, and three independent spread plates for spread plating. The gain is a factor of root-three reduction in the standard deviation of the final density estimate, which usually brings the coefficient of variation below 15 percent for routine QC.

Resources and references